As the holiday technology-buying season approaches (and also as the “drop dead” date for Windows XP nears… CLICK HERE to read more about THAT), questions are hitting my inbox, asking whether it makes more sense to purchase a tablet or go with a laptop with regards to mobile computing.
In fact just the other day, I was reading an article by a technology writer who was warning readers about 6 technology gifts you shouldn’t buy this holiday season (CLICK HERE to read her article).
One of their “don’t buy” suggestions included inexpensive (< $400) laptop computers.
The author’s point was that you can purchase a great tablet for less than a cheap laptop, and “get more out of it”.
According to the author (and she’s right), tablets tend to be more portable, have better battery life, and are less vulnerable to malware and viruses than laptops. So when you can get a Nexus 7 for $230, or a Kindle Fire HDX for $227, or an iPad Mini for $399, why would you spend the money on a laptop?
But here’s the deal from MY point of view.
I can’t argue that tablets aren’t awesome. Over the past few years, as I see more and more of my students come into the computer lab with tablets, I see a whole new world opening up to many folks who were too intimidated to really take advantage of what a computer has to offer.
Tablets make a lot of computer-related things a lot easier and more fun to do.
And I think that’s great! I love it when folks start using ANY technology as a tool to get things done.
But that doesn’t mean it’s time to throw away our laptop or desktop computers.
The fact is, each type of technology has it’s place in our busy world.
And that’s why I wish this author would have NOT included laptops on her list of things NOT to purchase.
Instead, she should have pointed out that different people have different technology goals, and that whether you should purchase a tablet or laptop depends on what you want to accomplish.
And that’s what I want to get across to all of my students here.
Both tablets and laptops have a place in the world of mobile computing, and which one you get depends on what you want to do.
Can you see the underlying theme here? For those tasks that require a lot of keyboard input, I still think that a computer (laptop for mobile computing) is the way to go. Even when you add an external keyboard to a tablet, creating documents, spreadsheets, and presentations is still too cumbersome for my taste.
In addition, the creation process also includes “saving stuff” (your files) which tends to be a bit more convoluted on a tablet. Most tablets do not have a true “folder system” like your computer does. Sure, there’s lots of cloud-based storage (iCloud for Apple, Dropbox and Google Drive for other tablets), but for many of my students, it’s just not as straight forward as saving things to a local hard drive.
So for those who have a need to “create things” and then “save those things”, laptops are the way to go.
Of course, the problem is… what if you are someone who wants to do multiple things, some of which a tablet does better, and some of which a laptop handles with more ease.
Well, you might then be a candidate for BOTH types of technology.
And that, truthfully, is where I see a LOT of folks headed… toward having both a tablet and a computer (either a desktop or a laptop). The
best of both worlds where the tool you are using (a tablet or laptop) at the moment depends upon what you are trying to do in that moment.
[By the way, there’s a “new breed” of laptop that includes a detachable screen which becomes a tablet. This type of hybrid laptop/tablet combination really does give you the best of both worlds! Of course, you pay for that flexibility with a higher price tag.]
So for those of you looking to purchase a mobile device this Christmas, make your choice by thinking about what you want do and then using the above list to determine whether a tablet or a laptop makes more sense.
If you want to read a bit more about the topic, last year I wrote a related article called “Kindle Fire, iPad, or a PC… Which one?” . You can CLICK HERE to read it.
As always, I’d love to hear about your own personal experiences with tablets and laptops (or any other technology for that matter)! Please leave a comment below…
And have fun shopping!!!